Haunted by the memory of Walter Holderlin, a soldier he killed during World War I, French musician Paul Renard (Phillips Holmes) confesses to a priest (Frank Sheridan), who grants him absolution. Using the address on a letter he found on the dead man's body, Paul then travels to Germany to find his family.
As anti-French sentiment continues to permeate Germany, Dr. Holderlin (Lionel Barrymore) initially refuses to welcome Paul into his home, but changes his mind when his son's fiancée Elsa identifies him as the man who has been leaving flowers on Walter's grave. Rather than reveal the real connection between them, Paul tells the Holderlin family he was a friend of their son, who attended the same musical conservatory he did.
Although the hostile townspeople and local gossips disapprove, the Holderlins befriend Paul, who finds himself falling in love with Elsa (Nancy Carroll). When she shows Paul her former fiancé's bedroom, he becomes distraught and tells her the truth. She convinces him not to confess to Walter's parents, who have embraced him as their second son, and Paul agrees to forego easing his conscience and stays with his adopted family. Dr. Holderlin presents Walter's violin to Paul, who plays it while Elsa accompanies him on the piano.
The film's original title, The Man I Killed, was changed to The Fifth Commandment to avoid giving "wrong impressions in the minds of the public about the character of the story." It ultimately was released as Broken Lullaby.
那种延绵的感情，静静敲进心里，随着他们共同欢乐与哀伤。在葬礼结束后，死亡换来了新生。当所有人挽着手出现围在小婴儿身旁，镜头一转定格于老夫人的画像。这让人恍惚间发现，原来任何的隔阂与阶级早已消失了，楼上与楼下，他们是相爱又无法分开的一个整体。
最后炭治郎在沉浸之中获得成长，用大招破解一切，也制作的非常出色，如果想要重温剧情，又觉得分集看比较麻烦，还是可以一看本片的。
野猪好可爱啊哈哈哈。黄毛在这篇里更可爱。为了保护祢豆子被揍得好惨哈哈哈哈哈。然后其实还挺强的啊。
一个婚礼加一个葬礼，我倒不觉得唐顿会落幕，20世界上半叶的大事还多着呢。
情怀是好的，唐顿庄园的火炬也传了下去。但是唐顿庄园这种琐碎日常的故事还是更适合电视剧的节奏吧，用一部电影讲述还是有些仓促，太想把每个方向都讲好了，就很有可能每个方面都不细致。
7.0分。秩序的魅力，优雅的魅力，古典的魅力，电影的魅力，全是其间了。
整体还行
TV版动画11-14集的合辑篇，主要内容就是三个主角第一次相遇，而后在一个会各种转换的房子里，炭治郎打败了下玄鬼，之后休养生息，准备前往蜘蛛山，相比较于原本的TV版，
编剧是有些连连看配对强迫症的，唐家屯上上下下相关人士就没有没个伴儿的，除了赛博老太太，她走了故事也就真正结束了，Mary和她也越来越像，继承遗志的真正掌舵人。我已从大小姐颜粉转为声控了。
元电影这层处理地很有意思。双线叙事增添了不少乐趣，可惜没多大关联。
还是熟悉的贵族庄园调调，这些年也对英式旧庄园和交际更熟悉了一点，看得更心领神会有趣得很。庄园出租拍电影，美国女演员的粗俗和口音真是惊到了所有人，奶奶还说她讲得很musical，英式拐弯抹角和讽刺好好玩，变成有声电影后时代默片女星当然被淘汰。另外一拨人去了南法，光是想想英国跟南法的温度差就替剧中人热死了。唐家屯这么多年了居然又出了一部！开心。巴罗先生老了不少。
马修古迪是没档期吗，大小姐明明还在婚姻中，但编剧还是硬给她凑一个暧昧对象，剧情整体还是过于戏剧化
没有了大表哥，片子的可看性下降了一半不止……情节转折和进入都太快了，比如导演莫名其妙就突然上头，像把电视剧调成了三倍速的效果。服化道也不如电视剧版。
好家伙这个房子是我梦中的场景啊，怎么都逃不出去
i hope you'll be as happy as our cruel world allows
我妻善逸前面实在太吵了，后来帅气的雷之呼吸、亲民的平凡感和强悍的吐槽力也没有完全挽回印象。伊之助则更是……呆萌的霸凌者就讨喜了吗？
oh 中间好好笑，只是大家都很完美的时候老太太却离开了。唐顿庄园太太太好看啦！
本集主要讲了两件事，老夫人被刚过世的年轻时的情人送了一个位于南法的度假别墅，有电影公司租用唐顿庄园拍电影，却正赶上从默片到有声片的过渡。
6.5/10 " 距上次在影院里看唐顿庄园故事的银幕首秀已经过去了三个年头，这批集结在一起的最具代表性的英国演员们在这部电影续集中仍然保持着他/她们的独有的魅力与风韵，并通过接踵而至的""人生大事""赋予了这段极具时代精神的本土家族史诗一种更绵长的生命力。片中开篇的婚礼与结尾的丧葬形成了奇妙的对照关系，一面是告别欢乐宴席的坦然，一面是迎接忧愁寂寞的释怀。在庄园建筑悠长历史投射的阴翳之下，这份""人情""显得温暖而珍贵。
想去南法！小茶杯的发际线啊… 一下没认出来。最喜欢的角色就是奶奶了，想看奶奶年轻的时候的故事。想看 Daisy 的婚礼没看到哼。大家一起拍电影太好玩了。
Copyright © 2015-2023 All Rights Reserved
